Have you read…? Thursday’s Child by Sonya Hartnett


Sonya Hartnett is one of my favourite authors. Her words are beautifully chosen and she is able to create phrases that perfectly encapsulate an emotion or sentiment. She writes about ‘growing up’ with great empathy. She must have very vivid memories of her own childhood and adolescence! These qualities and themes are evident in Thursday’s Child and are combined with the mythic qualities with which Hartnett infuses a number of her novels.

Thursday’s Child tells the story of the Flute family: Mam, Da, Audrey, Devon, Harper, Tin and Caffy, and is narrated by Harper. The Flute family is not well off. Da has returned from The Great War and has settled his family in the country. He makes a meagre living by trapping rabbits, their land unable to provide the family with crops as it is ‘particularly exhausted or maybe simply sullen’. When Caffy is born, Tin  takes refuge beneath their crowded home, digging away a series a tunnels and underground caves in which he houses himself. As the years progress, the family is hit hard by the Depression: rabbit pelts are no longer no longer in demand, Da makes well-intended, but poor, decisions and the family’s poverty is exploited by an unscrupulous neighbour. Tin becomes estranged from his family as he continues his life underground. Over the years we see him bring his family both ill fortune and good. Harper witnesses her family’s struggle but through the naïveté of a child’s eyes. In Hartnett’s beautiful prose, she describes the illumination that comes as one moves from childhood to adulthood

I had that same feeling I was getting more and more as I grew older, a feeling like I was trying to see through a fog or reach for something my fingers could touch but not wrap around…I was starting to realise the world is not one place , but two, and that you move from one to the other only with the years. I was living mostly in the first world, but I had a toe dipped in the second. The tip of a toe doesn’t tell you much…

I enjoyed Thursday’s Child but I understand how some may find the fantastical character of Tin jarring against the very real story of a family’s struggles  in the Depression. I chose, however, to allow myself to be taken by Hartnett’s beautiful writing into the imaginatively constructed world of the Flute family. If straight realism is more your cup of tea, perhaps Of a Boy or Golden Boys may be a safer choice.


2 thoughts on “Have you read…? Thursday’s Child by Sonya Hartnett

  1. Sonya Hartnett is one of my favourite authors too. I always struggle to describe why I enjoy her writing so much and you have expressed it so eloquently. I read Thursday’s child last year and just finished Of a Boy last week. Even a few days later it is still with me and I now have my Husband reading it so that we can chat about it ( hurry up and finish it already Steve). Which book should I read next Carolyn ? I love your book reviews!


    1. The line from Of a Boy that stays with me is ‘I’m not allowed to be anywhere’ – it is heartbreaking and gives that real sense of Adrian bring shunted from place to place. I’d give Butterfly a go next – as a child growing up in the 70s it really resonated with me and Golden Boys is excellent too. Happy that you like my reviews xx

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s